He gave Erin the deployment dates, his contact information, and the names of Lily’s school and pediatrician.
He also explained that his wife had been speaking to him through video calls throughout his deployment.
“I saw her face,” he said.
“I talked to her every week.”
Erin did not offer an easy explanation.
“People can look remarkably alike, especially close relatives,” she said.
“Investigators will need to establish what happened rather than rely on appearances alone.”
Daniel remembered the video calls differently now.
The camera had often been held at an angle.
The woman on screen had complained about poor lighting, headaches, and internet problems.
She had stopped wearing the necklace Daniel had given Rebecca on their fifth anniversary.
He had accepted every explanation because he wanted to believe his family was safe.
At noon, Officer Price returned with a detective named Marcus Hale.
The detective said the woman found in the basement had identified herself as Rebecca Carter and had documents supporting that identity.
The woman detained upstairs had identified herself as Rachel Mercer, Rebecca’s younger half sister.
Detective Hale emphasized that the investigation was still beginning.
“We need to know how she got access to your home and why your wife was kept downstairs,” he said.
“We also need to know whether anyone else helped her.”
Daniel looked at Lily, who was drawing a house with a blue roof on a sheet of hospital paper.
“My daughter was there the entire time.”
“We understand.”
“She was six years old.”
Detective Hale held his gaze.
“That is why we’re being careful with her account.”
When Daniel finally entered Rebecca’s room, she was sitting upright with a cup of broth in her hands.
Her face was thinner than he remembered, but the way she tucked her hair behind her ear was unmistakable.
He sat beside the bed.
“Tell me how this started.”
Rebecca stared at the untouched broth.
“Rachel came in June,” she said.
“She told me she had nowhere else to go.”
CHAPTER FIVE — THE FIRST LIE
Rebecca had not seen Rachel in eleven years.
Their father had left Rebecca’s mother when Rebecca was nine, and Rachel had been born into his second marriage.
The girls spent summers together for a few years before their father’s drinking and arguments divided the households.
Rachel grew up hearing that Rebecca had received every opportunity she had been denied.
By adulthood, their relationship had become a collection of unanswered letters and one uncomfortable funeral.