A woman emerged through the front doorway wrapped in a gray blanket.

She was pale, thin, and unsteady on her feet.

Her hair had been cut short above her shoulders.

There was a small crescent-shaped scar above her left eyebrow.

Daniel knew the scar because he had been there when she got it, years earlier, after falling against a cabinet while carrying Lily’s crib.

“Rebecca?” he said.

The woman stopped walking.

For a moment she looked at him without recognition, as if her eyes were refusing to trust what they saw.

Then she whispered his name.

Daniel took one step forward, but the paramedic asked him to wait while they assessed her condition.

The woman reached toward Lily.

Lily pulled away from Daniel and ran across the grass.

“Mommy!”

The paramedic knelt beside the woman as Lily wrapped her arms around her waist.

Daniel watched his daughter bury her face in the gray blanket with a relief so desperate it hurt to witness.

He had spent nine months imagining the moment his family would be together again.

He had never imagined that he would need police officers to make it possible.

The woman looked over Lily’s head at him.

“Daniel, that woman isn’t me,” she said.

He nodded, unable to speak.

“Her name is Rachel.”

Daniel’s mouth went dry.

“Rachel who?”

The real Rebecca closed her eyes.

“My sister.”

CHAPTER FOUR — THE SISTER WHO DISAPPEARED

Daniel had never met anyone named Rachel.

He knew Rebecca had a sister named Caroline because Caroline had attended their wedding and sent Christmas cards.

He knew Rebecca’s parents were dead and that her family rarely discussed the years before college.

He did not know there had been another sister.

At the hospital, a nurse helped Rebecca into clean clothes while Daniel sat beside Lily in a family waiting room.

Lily had eaten a sandwich and half a cup of applesauce, but she still hid the extra crackers in her pocket.

Daniel noticed and said nothing until she caught him looking.

“You can keep those,” he told her.

“There will be more food when you’re hungry.”

She nodded without appearing convinced.

A social worker named Erin Bell came to speak with them.

Erin explained that Lily would need a medical examination and a careful interview with a child specialist, and that no one wanted Daniel to question her repeatedly about what happened.

Daniel appreciated the instruction because he could feel his own questions pressing against his teeth.