It was the first time mother and daughter had spent a quiet afternoon in that room since the rescue.

Daniel stayed nearby without trying to direct their conversation.

Lily held up the blue whale.

“I brought him to the hospital,” she told Rebecca.

“He helped me,” Rebecca answered.

“He says you can sleep here when you’re ready.”

Rebecca’s smile trembled.

“I would like that very much.”

Later, Daniel found his wife standing in the doorway of the basement hall.

The lock had been removed, and a contractor had inspected the damaged door.

The basement itself was empty except for a few stored boxes that investigators had returned.

Rebecca stared down the stairs.

“I don’t think I can go down there yet,” she said.

“You don’t have to.”

“I don’t want Lily to think the basement is still dangerous.”

“We can teach her that the danger was what happened, not the stairs.”

Rebecca rested her hand against the wall.

“I keep hearing her footsteps overhead.”

Daniel stood beside her.

“I keep hearing the knocking.”

They did not pretend those sounds would disappear because the door was open.

That night, Lily asked Daniel to read the same picture book twice.

He read it twice without looking at the clock.

When he finished, she touched the sleeve of his shirt.

“Daddy, do you think people can be two different people?”

Daniel thought of Rachel wearing Rebecca’s clothes and using her name.

“Sometimes people pretend to be someone they’re not,” he said.

Lily shook her head.

“I mean can somebody be nice and mean?”

He considered the question carefully.

“Yes, sweetheart.”

“How do you know which one is real?”

“You look at how they treat people, especially when nobody else is watching.”

Lily settled beneath her blanket.

“Mommy was always nice to me.”

“She loves you very much.”

“I know.”

Daniel turned off the lamp but left the hallway light on.

From downstairs came the soft sound of Rebecca and Mrs. Alvarez laughing over a spilled cup of tea.

It was a small sound, and it belonged to the house again.

CHAPTER SEVENTEEN — THE EMPTY CHAIR

On the first Monday after Rebecca began visiting the house, Lily asked why her mother still left before dinner.

Daniel was rinsing strawberries at the kitchen sink, and the question caught him with his hands under running water.

Rebecca had spent three hours helping Lily build a paper town on the living room rug.