The couple agreed to provide any family records they still possessed.

Rebecca went to Claire’s apartment that afternoon and opened the cedar chest their grandmother had left behind.

Inside were holiday cards, a faded quilt, and a photograph of two young girls standing beside a porch swing.

One girl was Rebecca, smiling with a missing front tooth.

The other was Rachel, her hand resting on Rebecca’s shoulder.

Rebecca stared at the photograph for a long time.

“She wasn’t always like this,” Claire said quietly.

Rebecca placed the picture on the table.

“I know.”

“You can remember who she was without excusing what she did.”

Rebecca looked at her sister.

“I don’t know which memories are safe anymore.”

Claire pulled out a chair and sat beside her.

“Then we can sort them out one at a time.”

That evening, Rebecca brought the old photograph home.

She showed it to Daniel after Lily went to bed.

“I don’t want Lily to grow up believing every happy memory is a lie,” she said.

Daniel studied the two girls on the porch swing.

“Then we’ll tell her the truth in pieces she can understand.”

“What truth?”

“That someone can have been part of your family and still be responsible for terrible choices.”

Rebecca set the photograph facedown.

For the first time, she was willing to consider that the past could be complicated without controlling the future.

CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR — THE CALL FROM THE PROSECUTOR

The prosecutor called on a Tuesday while Daniel was helping Lily tape paper stars to her bedroom ceiling.

Daniel stepped into the hallway so his daughter would not hear the conversation.

Investigators had completed a significant portion of their review, and the prosecutor expected additional court proceedings to be scheduled.

Some of the financial allegations would be addressed alongside the allegations involving Rebecca’s confinement and Lily’s treatment.

The prosecutor emphasized that charges were allegations and that the court process would determine the outcome.

Daniel appreciated the precision even as he wished for something simpler.

He asked whether Rebecca would need to describe her experience in detail again.

“We will discuss the options with her and make sure she understands each step,” the prosecutor said.

“We won’t ask you to decide for her.”

Daniel looked through the bedroom doorway.

Lily was standing on a chair, reaching for a paper star just beyond her fingertips.

“That’s fair,” he answered.

After the call, he told Rebecca everything he had been told and nothing more.