He had believed those stories because they sounded like ordinary difficulties in a household under pressure.

“She worked hard to make people believe her,” he said.

“That doesn’t make what she did your responsibility.”

Mrs. Alvarez looked toward the backyard, where Lily was standing on tiptoe to hang the feeder.

“I still wish I had noticed sooner.”

Daniel could not tell her that wishing was useless.

He wished the same thing every morning.

Instead, he said, “You noticed that Lily was scared when she came to your porch.”

“You stayed with her when she needed somebody.”

Mrs. Alvarez wiped her hands on her apron.

“I’ll tell the detective whatever I remember.”

Later that evening, Daniel watched Lily examine the feeder through the window.

A sparrow landed on the fence, hesitated, and flew away.

Lily sighed dramatically.

“Birds don’t trust new things right away.”

Rebecca came to stand beside her.

“Sometimes they need to watch for a while,” she said.

Lily nodded as though she had discovered a rule that applied to more than birds.

CHAPTER TWENTY-EIGHT — A LETTER FROM THE DEFENSE

The letter arrived at Daniel’s attorney’s office rather than at the Carter house.

Its careful language requested a voluntary meeting between Rebecca and a representative of Rachel’s defense team.

The stated purpose was to explore whether certain disputed property and financial issues could be resolved before trial.

Daniel read the copy while standing in the attorney’s waiting room.

“Absolutely not,” he said.

Rebecca, seated across from him, held out her hand.

“Let me read it.”

He gave her the letter.

She took her time with each paragraph and asked their attorney, Helen Ward, what would happen if she refused.

“Nothing about this request requires you to meet them,” Helen said.

“Any settlement discussion would need to be handled carefully, and the criminal case remains separate.”

Rebecca read the final paragraph again.

The letter did not apologize for her confinement or mention Lily by name.

It referred to a family misunderstanding and contested control of household assets.

“She still wants to call it a misunderstanding,” Rebecca said.

Helen reminded her that a defense attorney was entitled to advocate for a client.

That did not require Rebecca to accept the description.

“I don’t want a meeting,” Rebecca decided.

“If there are documents she wants returned, they can be identified through the proper process.”

Daniel sat down beside her.

He had been ready to fight the moment he saw the envelope, but Rebecca had made the decision without raising her voice.