The third knock came from the other side of the basement door, and Daniel Carter felt his daughter’s fingers tighten around his wrist.

It was not the kind of sound a loose pipe made when the heating system started.

Three deliberate strikes had come through the wood, followed by a silence so complete that Daniel could hear the kitchen refrigerator humming behind him.

Rebecca stood halfway down the stairs, one hand pressed against the banister.

Her face had lost every trace of the smile she had worn when she first saw him.

“Who is downstairs?” Daniel asked.

“Nobody,” she answered too quickly.

Lily pressed her cheek against his uniform sleeve.

“Daddy, she said the knocking was the washing machine.”

Daniel looked toward the narrow hallway beside the pantry.

The basement door was painted the same pale gray as the kitchen cabinets, but its brass lock was new.

He remembered a cheap round knob there before his deployment.

He remembered leaving the basement unlocked because the circuit breaker and water shutoff were downstairs.

Now a heavy deadbolt sat above the handle, and someone had scratched the paint around its keyhole.

“Rebecca, get away from the stairs and tell me what happened here.”

His wife came down another step.

“You can’t walk in after nine months and start issuing orders like this is your barracks.”

Daniel did not raise his voice.

“Our daughter is eating food off the floor and begging me not to tell you.”

“She has been difficult since you left.”

“That doesn’t answer my question.”

“You don’t know what it has been like.”

Daniel glanced down at the folded photograph in his hand.

The picture showed Lily standing beside Rebecca in a yellow dress at a county fair.

He recognized the dress because he had bought it before leaving for deployment.

He recognized the fairground sign because he had taken the photograph himself the previous summer.

But the woman beside Lily had a small crescent-shaped scar above her left eyebrow.

The Rebecca on the staircase did not.

That was the first difference Daniel could see clearly.

The second was the wedding ring.

The woman in the photograph wore Rebecca’s narrow silver band with a tiny blue stone beside the diamond.

The woman standing before him wore a plain gold ring.

He had noticed the ring when he hugged her goodbye at the airport, but the detail had not seemed important until this moment.