It showed a girl holding a key above a staircase.
Underneath, in careful first-grade handwriting, Lily had written, “I WILL FIND MOMMY.”
Daniel sat back in the tiny classroom chair.
He had been preparing to surprise his daughter with a stuffed bear and a trip for ice cream.
Lily had been preparing to rescue her mother.
He asked Ms. Foster whether Lily could return to school without classmates being told what happened.
The teacher promised to work with the principal and counselor to protect Lily’s privacy as much as possible.
When Daniel picked Lily up, she ran toward him carrying a spelling worksheet.
He knelt and held out his arms.
This time she did not look over her shoulder before hugging him.
CHAPTER NINE — THE SIGNATURE IN THE WRONG PLACE
The first envelope arrived on a Thursday morning, four days after Daniel met Lily’s teacher.
It had no return address, only a printed label bearing Rebecca Carter’s name.
Daniel found it beneath the grocery advertisements and nearly put it aside with the rest of the mail.
Then he noticed the postage date.
The envelope had been mailed while Rebecca was still trapped downstairs.
Inside was a notice from a storage facility on the other side of town.
It thanked Rebecca for opening a climate-controlled unit and reminded her that the next payment would be due in fourteen days.
Daniel read the address twice.
He had never heard Rebecca mention renting storage space.
He photographed the notice and called Detective Hale before touching anything else.
Hale asked him to bring the original to the station rather than visiting the facility himself.
Daniel hated how often the safest answer required waiting.
For nine months overseas, he had followed instructions because other people’s lives depended on discipline.
Now he was standing in his own kitchen, struggling not to drive straight across town and demand answers from a stranger behind a counter.
He looked toward the breakfast table.
Lily was sitting in a chair with her feet swinging above the floor, eating scrambled eggs from a blue plate.
She had asked to use that plate because it had a painted whale on the rim.
Daniel had bought it years earlier and forgotten it existed.
The fact that she remembered it made him ashamed of how many ordinary things he had missed.
“Is Mommy coming home today?” she asked.
“The doctors are still helping her get stronger,” Daniel said.