Officer Price listened without interrupting.

Then she asked Daniel whether he had seen or heard anyone physically inside the basement.

“I heard three knocks and a voice,” he said.

“I haven’t opened the door.”

“Do you have a key?”

Lily suddenly reached into her dress pocket.

She produced a tiny brass key attached to a pink plastic star.

“I found it in the laundry basket,” she whispered.

Daniel stared at it.

Rebecca had told him during a video call that the basement was flooded and sealed for repairs.

Now the little key in Lily’s palm looked painfully real.

CHAPTER THREE — THE WOMAN BEHIND THE DOOR

The officers did not rush blindly into the basement.

They separated Daniel and Rebecca, checked the house for immediate danger, and asked whether anyone needed help.

Rebecca insisted the basement was empty.

She said the knocking came from a loose dryer vent, although Daniel knew the dryer stood upstairs beside the kitchen.

Officer Price repeated the question.

“Is there a person downstairs who cannot come out?”

Rebecca’s lips moved before any sound emerged.

“My sister has been staying with us.”

Daniel felt the porch railing press against his palm.

Rebecca had one sister, Caroline, who lived in Colorado and had visited them twice in ten years.

“Which sister?” he asked.

Rebecca ignored him.

The officer asked for the sister’s name.

“Caroline,” Rebecca said.

“Why is the door locked?”

“She isn’t well.”

“Is she being held there against her will?”

“Of course not.”

Officer Price asked Rebecca to unlock the door.

Rebecca claimed she had misplaced the key.

Daniel looked at the little brass key in Lily’s hand and realized his daughter had been carrying something more dangerous than a secret.

He asked Lily to give it to the officer.

She hesitated only long enough to make sure he would not let go of her other hand.

Officer Price took the key, returned inside with her partner, and told Daniel to remain outside with Lily.

The next several minutes passed slowly enough for Daniel to hear individual birds calling from the hedge.

Then the basement door opened.

A woman’s voice rose from inside the house.

“Please don’t let her take me back down there.”

Daniel stood so quickly that Lily stumbled against his leg.

He caught her and stayed where the officer had instructed.

A second patrol car pulled to the curb.

A paramedic unit followed.

Rebecca appeared briefly in the hallway, speaking loudly, but an officer guided her into the living room.