“I hate that every normal memory now comes with a question,” she said.

I put my arm around her.

“We can ask questions without surrendering every good memory,” I said.

She looked toward the backyard.

“Then we should start with the birthday.”

That evening, we asked Isaiah what he wanted to do about the party he never got to finish.

He thought for a long time.

“I don’t want another big party,” he said.

“I just want my friends to come over and eat cake.”

It was the first time he had asked to celebrate anything since the incident.

CHAPTER THIRTY-SEVEN: FOSTER TAKES THE STAND

Officer Daniel Foster appeared before an administrative review panel several weeks later.

The proceeding was not a criminal trial, and its purpose was limited to departmental conduct.

Still, his testimony mattered to everyone who had watched the backyard video.

Foster described arriving behind Coleman and hearing children scream.

He said he had initially believed they were responding to a trespassing complaint.

Then he saw the decorations, the adults, and the frightened children pressed near the wall.

He testified that Coleman had not explained any immediate danger requiring that response.

He also described the moment when dispatch information contradicted Coleman’s account of the call.

The panel asked why Foster had challenged his partner in front of the family.

Foster answered without raising his voice.

“Because children were being threatened, and the facts I had did not support what was happening,” he said.

One panel member asked whether he had worried about his career.

“Yes,” Foster answered.

“But I was more worried about what would happen if I stayed quiet.”

Coleman’s attorney challenged Foster’s recollection and pointed to the confusion of a fast-moving call.

Foster acknowledged that he had not heard every word Coleman said before entering the yard.

He refused to claim otherwise.

The panel reviewed dispatch records and available video footage separately from his testimony.

I did not attend the hearing.

My judicial position and the pending proceedings made distance essential.

Camille later explained the portions that had been released publicly.

The department had sustained findings that Coleman had violated several conduct policies.

Other allegations remained under review.

Coleman continued to dispute the findings through the available process.

I read the summary at home after the children had gone to bed.

For the first time, the account of what happened in our backyard existed in an official record that did not depend on my job title.