He looked toward the upstairs window again.

That was when I understood the person who had sent him knew the location of the evidence.

Three nights earlier, someone had tried to open the study door.

Now a police officer had appeared at my son’s birthday party with a story that did not match dispatch.

The connection was too serious to ignore.

It was also too early to call it proof.

I had spent years learning the difference.

I was a federal judge, but that title did not give me authority over a local officer standing in my yard.

It did give me a clear understanding of how easily an assumption could ruin a case.

I needed witnesses, records, and a careful account of what had actually happened.

I did not need a dramatic confrontation.

Coleman seemed to want one.

He stepped toward me and asked whether I intended to make a complaint.

I said I intended to document the incident.

He laughed without humor.

He said people like me always thought paperwork could solve everything.

Foster told him to stop talking.

Coleman turned toward his partner with open disbelief.

I heard a siren approaching from the street.

A second patrol car stopped beyond the fence.

Coleman straightened his shoulders as though he expected reinforcements.

I watched the gate open.

A woman in a police supervisor’s uniform entered the backyard.

She looked at the children through the kitchen window.

Then she looked at the cake in the pool.

Her nameplate read HARRIS.

She asked which officer had requested assistance.

Foster raised his hand.

Coleman began speaking before anyone else could answer.

He said the family had become hostile during a trespassing investigation.

Sergeant Harris held up one hand.

She asked Foster for the dispatch number.

Coleman stopped speaking.

I saw something pass across his face that looked very much like fear.

CHAPTER TWO: THE CALL THAT DID NOT EXIST

Sergeant Angela Harris had a calm voice that made people lower theirs.

She listened while Foster explained the original dispatch information.

He said he had been told to assist with a possible property complaint.

Coleman had described it as a neighbor’s report about trespassers using a pool.

The actual call record contained no such report.

Harris asked Coleman where he had obtained that description.

He said dispatch had summarized it incorrectly.

Foster said the dispatch summary had been available on both patrol terminals.

Coleman claimed his screen had frozen.