The process was moving slowly because evidence could not be treated as reliable merely because it supported an obvious theory.

I thought about the photograph of the birthday cake sinking into the pool.

That moment had been captured by several phones.

The reason behind it remained hidden in paper trails and contradictory statements.

Before I left, Camille gave me one additional fact.

The floor plan in the envelope was not the version submitted when our house was built.

It showed a small interior change made less than a year earlier.

Only a handful of contractors had seen that revision.

One of them had worked for Northline Services.

CHAPTER THIRTY-SIX: THE CONTRACTOR’S ACCOUNT

Aaron Pike requested a meeting with investigators after learning that his name appeared in a report about our house.

He was the Northline employee who had performed a maintenance visit months earlier.

His account reached us through Camille after the investigators determined what could be shared.

Pike said he had been assigned to inspect a ventilation problem near the upstairs storage room.

He had photographed the affected wall for a routine service record.

His supervisor later asked him to send the pictures to a separate project folder.

Pike thought the request was unusual but assumed the company needed documentation for an insurance question.

He did not know the folder was connected to Kessler.

He said he had never met Coleman.

He also denied knowing about Isaiah’s birthday party before the incident became public.

The investigators compared Pike’s original photographs with the images found in Kessler’s records.

Several appeared to match.

One image had been cropped to remove a service tag that identified the contractor.

The alteration mattered because it suggested the photographs had been prepared for a purpose other than documenting repairs.

Pike supplied his work messages and the name of the supervisor who had requested the separate folder.

That supervisor had resigned from Northline shortly after the party.

I read the summary twice.

There was no dramatic confession.

There was only an ordinary employee describing an ordinary assignment that someone else had turned into something dangerous.

Renee read it beside me at the kitchen counter.

“He walked through our hallway,” she said.

“I offered him coffee.”

I remembered the visit.

Olivia had been home sick from school and had watched cartoons beneath a blanket.

The contractor had apologized for the noise of his tools.

Nothing about that afternoon had seemed threatening.

Renee set the pages down.