He had already given an initial statement, but he wanted to correct one detail.
Sergeant Harris later told our family attorney that the correction might matter to the broader inquiry.
I did not learn the full account until it was provided through the appropriate process weeks later.
Foster had been in the patrol car with Coleman when the dispatch assignment appeared on their terminal.
The written summary described a suspicious person near a residential property.
It did not mention a birthday party or trespassing children.
Coleman had looked at his phone immediately after reading the address.
Then he had told Foster that a neighbor had reported a group using a private pool without permission.
Foster had asked whether the neighbor was the homeowner.
Coleman had said the homeowner was away.
At the time, Foster believed his partner had received additional information.
He had not asked how.
When they reached our street, Coleman parked half a block away rather than in front of the house.
He told Foster to check the side yard while he went through the back gate.
Foster objected that they should first contact the residents.
Coleman insisted there was an urgent risk of trespassers entering the house.
Foster followed him because he did not want to leave his partner alone during a potentially volatile encounter.
He later said that choice had been a mistake.
He should have challenged the unsupported urgency before anyone entered the fenced yard.
The investigators asked him what happened when Coleman saw the children.
Foster said Coleman appeared angry rather than surprised.
He shouted orders that had no obvious connection to an immediate safety concern.
Then he picked up the cake.
Foster said he had never seen an officer do anything like it.
He remembered the sound of the cake hitting the pool because it came before the children started screaming.
He remembered Olivia trying to hide behind a lawn chair.
He remembered Isaiah asking why the police were ruining his birthday.
The investigator asked why Foster had not physically stopped Coleman.
Foster said the events unfolded quickly and that he initially tried to stop the behavior with verbal commands.
He acknowledged that his response had not protected the children soon enough.
His honesty did not erase what happened.
It did make his account more useful than a polished excuse.
During the interview, Foster described something else.
Coleman’s phone had vibrated shortly before they entered the yard.
Foster saw a message preview flash across the screen.