The sender claimed to be Teresa Nolan.
She said she had found one more page tucked inside her old calendar.
The page was a copy of a visitor log from Richard Vale’s office.
It listed a meeting on the afternoon the false acknowledgment was prepared.
Richard’s name appeared beside Evelyn’s.
A third name had been entered in the visitor column.
I opened the attached photograph and enlarged the handwriting.
The name was not Connor’s.
It was Hannah’s mother’s name.
I stared at the screen as the meaning settled over me.
The person who had told Hannah that Connor abandoned her might have been present when the false proof of that abandonment was created.
And Hannah had spent twelve years trusting the very person who may have helped keep her daughter from knowing her father.
I read Teresa’s message three times before I trusted myself to move.
The visitor log showed a date, a time, and three signatures written in the same narrow column.
Richard Vale had signed first, Evelyn Marsh had signed beneath him, and the third signature belonged to Patricia Whitcomb.
Patricia was Hannah’s mother and Sophie’s grandmother.
I knew her name because Miriam had mentioned her during an earlier conversation about the family history.
Hannah had described Patricia as the person who supported her when she became pregnant and believed Connor had abandoned her.
The photograph on my phone did not prove that Patricia had helped forge anything.
It proved only that she had been in Richard’s office on a day she had never mentioned.
That was enough to make me afraid of what the next conversation would do to Hannah.
I called Teresa instead of sending the photograph straight to Connor.
She answered on the fourth ring, sounding tired and wary.
I introduced myself and thanked her for finding the page.
She asked whether Miriam had already seen it.
I admitted that I had not forwarded it yet.
“Please send it to her before anyone starts asking questions,” Teresa said.
“Why are you worried?” I asked.
“Because I remember what happened to people who asked Richard questions without a lawyer present.”
She told me that the original visitor book had been stored in the front office for years.
When the company moved, she had copied several pages because they related to a complaint she was preparing against her supervisor.
Patricia’s signature happened to be on one of those pages.
Teresa had not recognized the importance of the name until she compared it with Miriam’s list of people connected to Sophie.
“Did you see Patricia that day?” I asked.
“I saw a woman with that name on her visitor badge, but I didn’t know who she was.”
“Was she carrying anything?”
“A manila folder and a little white purse.”
Teresa hesitated before adding that the woman had cried in the parking lot after the meeting.
A young receptionist had offered her water, but Patricia had refused and driven away.