“She says she did,” Miriam answered.
“Do you believe her?”
“I believe that we need evidence before we decide who knew what.”
It was a careful answer, and I respected her for giving it.
Before we ended the call, she warned me that helping Connor with the document would not change the separate decisions he was making about our marriage.
I told her I understood.
I said it more confidently than I felt.
That evening, I went into the garage with a flashlight and opened boxes we had not touched since moving into the house.
There were holiday decorations, college notebooks, old appliance manuals, and a collection of photographs Connor had kept long before he met me.
I found the company picnic picture tucked inside a yellow envelope.
Connor stood beneath a striped canopy with three coworkers, all holding paper plates and laughing at something outside the frame.
The woman in the baseball cap stood beside him.
I turned the photograph over.
Someone had written a date and four first names in blue ink.
Evelyn was one of them.
I took a clear photograph of both sides and sent it to Miriam.
Then I sat on the garage floor and looked at Connor’s younger face.
He was twenty-six in that picture, with a careless smile I had rarely seen during the final months of our marriage.
I wondered how many versions of him I had never bothered to know.
My phone buzzed before I could put the photograph away.
Blake had sent a message asking why I had stopped answering him.
I had blocked his calls after Connor left, but I had forgotten one messaging account we had used.
His words filled the screen with the easy confidence I had once mistaken for affection.
He wanted to know whether my husband had finally moved out.
He suggested we celebrate with dinner at the waterfront restaurant where we had spent so many secret evenings.
I read the message twice.
Three months earlier, the invitation would have made me feel chosen.
Now it made me feel like someone who had been watching a house burn while admiring the color of the flames.
I wrote that our relationship was over and that I did not want him to contact me again.
He replied immediately.
“You don’t get to use me and then pretend you’re innocent.”
The accusation stung because it contained a truth I could not avoid.
I had used Blake to escape boredom and used Connor’s patience to avoid consequences.
I told Blake that I was not claiming innocence.
Then I blocked the account.
I sat in the garage until the motion sensor light went dark.
When I finally stood, I carried the photograph into the house instead of returning it to the box.
I placed it beside the copy of the questionable signature.
For once, I wanted to finish something difficult instead of walking away from it.