I felt a chill.
“Did she agree?”
“She says she did.”
Connor opened the folder and showed me a photocopy of Evelyn’s signed statement.
The details were specific enough to be checked against payroll records and travel dates.
Miriam had warned him that Evelyn’s memory could be challenged after so many years.
Even so, her admission changed the case.
The disputed letter no longer looked like a simple misunderstanding.
Someone had deliberately created a false record of Connor receiving information.
“Why would Richard care whether you knew about Sophie?” I asked.
Connor rubbed the bridge of his nose.
“That’s the part I haven’t told you.”
He looked out the window before continuing.
“Sophie’s mother, Hannah, was Richard’s stepdaughter.”
The words seemed to move the room around me.
I knew almost nothing about Hannah beyond her name and the fact that she had once been involved with Connor.
Connor had said they dated briefly before he met me.
I had assumed their lives separated naturally.
Now I understood that a family connection had stood between them.
“Richard was her stepfather?” I repeated.
Connor nodded.
“He married her mother when Hannah was seventeen.”
“Did you know that when you dated her?”
“Yes.”
He admitted that the relationship had been complicated from the beginning.
Hannah was working toward a nursing degree, and Connor had recently joined the engineering firm.
They met at a community fundraiser and began seeing each other quietly.
Richard disliked the relationship, though he never explained his objections directly.
He told Connor that personal entanglements could damage a promising career.
Connor thought the warning was arrogant but harmless.
Then Richard offered him a major assignment out of state.
Connor accepted because it seemed like an opportunity he could not afford to refuse.
Hannah told him she supported the move.
They agreed to stay in touch, but the calls became less frequent as the distance strained their relationship.
Eventually, Hannah ended things by phone.
She said she needed to focus on school and her family.
Connor was hurt, but he believed her.
He had no reason to think she was pregnant.
“She tried to contact me later,” he said.
“That’s what the letter was supposed to be about.”
I thought of the fake signature.
“And Richard intercepted it.”
“That’s what we suspect.”
Connor was careful not to state a conclusion the evidence had not yet established.
He said Hannah had kept a copy of the letter in a box of family papers.
She believed a lawyer working for her stepfather had delivered it to Connor.
When she later received a copy with his acknowledgment, she thought he had chosen not to be involved.
Her mother encouraged her to move on.
Hannah eventually stopped asking.
I stared at the steam rising from my coffee.
“Did she ever confront you directly?”
“Not until this year.”
Connor explained that Hannah had recently discovered the old letter while sorting records after her mother’s death.