The first thing twelve year old Maya Brooks remembered was the sharp smell of chemicals drifting across the swimming pool.

The second was the sound of her little brother crying for their father.

Officer Daniel Mercer stood beside the deep end with a canister in his hand while children stumbled backward through a cloud of irritating spray.

A birthday banner sagged between two trees, and a paper plate floated slowly across the water.

Maya had spent all morning decorating the backyard for her brother Noah, who had turned nine that Saturday.

Now Noah crouched behind a patio chair with his hands over his face.

Their mother, Simone Brooks, pulled him toward the outdoor shower and called for everyone to move away from the pool.

She did not scream at the officer because the children needed to hear clear instructions more than they needed to hear her anger.

Mercer kept his free hand near his belt and demanded that the guests leave the property.

He claimed the party had become a public disturbance, although the house stood behind a locked wooden gate on a quiet residential street outside Richmond.

Simone told him that the children were guests in her own home and that she had not given him permission to enter.

Mercer answered by pointing toward the neighboring fence.

He said someone had reported trespassers using a pool without authorization.

Maya stared at him because she had watched her father sign the closing papers for this house the previous winter.

Her father had shown her the little brass key to the back gate and told her that their family finally had a place where they could breathe.

Now a uniformed stranger was telling her that she did not belong there.

The gate creaked behind the officer.

A man in a pale blue shirt stepped into the yard carrying a cardboard box of birthday candles.

His name was Nathan Brooks, and he had spent the previous hour buying the special chocolate cake Noah wanted.

He stopped when he saw the children coughing beside the patio.

He placed the box on the nearest table and walked directly toward his son.

Mercer ordered him to stay where he was.

Nathan ignored the order long enough to help Noah rinse his face with clean water.

Only after Simone assured him that every child was being cared for did he turn toward the officer.

Nathan asked Mercer to identify the immediate danger that had justified using a chemical irritant around children.

Mercer said the children had refused to comply with his commands.

Nathan looked toward the pool and counted the frightened faces.