Still, it contained one document that neither lawyer had expected.
A meeting calendar showed that Captain Voss, Lieutenant Redd, and a civilian risk consultant had attended a briefing titled Community Exposure Review on the morning of Ethan’s arrest.
The consultant’s name was Martin Keller.
Ethan recognized it immediately from Marisol’s voicemail.
Naomi compared the spelling twice.
“We have a name in two places,” she said.
“We don’t have proof that it’s the same person.”
“But we can find out,” Ethan replied.
The consultant worked for a firm called Civic Shield Strategies.
Its public website described services in municipal risk management, communications planning, and litigation response.
Nothing on the website suggested that the firm had authority to direct police operations.
The city’s contract summary described the firm’s role as advisory.
Ethan wondered why an outside adviser might contact a citizen who had filed a complaint against the police.
He asked Naomi to request the scope of the firm’s contract and any communications involving the affected residents.
She agreed, but warned him that some documents might be withheld under legal privilege claims.
“Then we challenge the claims when we have a basis,” Ethan said.
“We don’t invent one.”
Naomi smiled briefly.
“You’re learning to be a patient client.”
“Don’t get used to it.”
By Friday, a local reporter named Tessa Monroe had learned about the preservation proceeding.
She called Ethan and asked whether he believed the police department maintained a list of critics.
Ethan declined to characterize records he had not seen.
He confirmed only that his legal team was seeking information about the handling of his arrest and the integrity of related dispatch records.
Tessa sounded disappointed.
“You could make this a much bigger story,” she said.
“It already matters to the people involved,” Ethan replied.
“I don’t need to make it bigger than the facts.”
After the call, he found an envelope slipped beneath his office door.
There was no return address.
Inside was a photocopy of a page labeled Operational Integrity Tracker, followed by a list of case numbers.
Several case numbers matched complaints Ethan had handled.
Beside each number was a short classification.
One read persistent complainant.
Another read elevated reputational exposure.
The entry beside Ethan’s own name read priority containment.
Naomi arrived while he was still staring at the page.
“Don’t touch it any more than you already have,” she said.
“We need to document how it arrived.”
Ethan placed the sheet on the desk.
“Look at the date.”
The page had been generated four days before his arrest.
Naomi read the header and then examined the bottom corner.
“There’s no authentication mark,” she said.