Ethan thought about his father, who had taught him that the right to ask questions meant little if officials could punish the questioner.
He had repeated that lesson in courtrooms for years.
Now the lesson had reached his own front door.
The next morning brought the first official response to Naomi’s preservation demand.
The city attorney’s office acknowledged receipt and promised to take reasonable steps to preserve relevant materials.
It did not confirm whether the department still possessed the complete audit history.
Naomi called the answer carefully worded.
Ethan called it a beginning.
They filed a petition seeking expedited preservation of electronic evidence and explained why ordinary retention schedules could endanger the records.
They did not ask a judge to decide the merits of Ethan’s claims before discovery.
They asked the court to keep the evidence from disappearing while those claims were examined.
At the same time, Ethan’s existing clients began receiving unfamiliar calls.
One woman, Marisol Vega, said a stranger had contacted her and claimed Ethan was using her case to pursue a personal grudge.
Another client reported that a man identifying himself as a department liaison had encouraged him to withdraw his complaint.
Neither caller had threatened violence.
Both had used details the clients believed were private.
Ethan instructed his team to document the contacts without confronting the callers.
He also reminded his clients that they were free to choose their own representation.
He refused to make their cases subordinate to his personal fight.
That evening, Marisol came to his office with her adult daughter, Isabel.
Marisol had been stopped outside a grocery store six months earlier after an officer mistakenly identified her vehicle as stolen.
The mistake was corrected within minutes, but she alleged that officers searched her car after she refused consent.
Her complaint had been closed without a sustained finding.
Ethan had obtained security footage from the grocery store showing the exchange from a distance.
The footage did not capture every word, but it contradicted part of the officers’ written timeline.
Marisol placed a handwritten telephone number on Ethan’s desk.
“He said I should stop talking to you,” she told him.
“Did he identify himself?” Ethan asked.
“He said his name was Mr. Keller.”
“Did he say where he worked?”
“He said he represented people who wanted to resolve this quietly.”
Isabel leaned forward.
“He knew my mother’s address and the date of her complaint.”
Naomi asked whether they had saved the voicemail.
Isabel nodded and played it.
The caller’s voice was calm and practiced.
He described the complaint as a misunderstanding and suggested that continued litigation could become expensive.
He never explicitly ordered Marisol to withdraw.