Cyrus wrote that he was ashamed of his silence, but he was even more ashamed that he had begun to treasure those visits.
Roberta had treated him kindly without knowing his connection to her father.
She had asked about his health, remembered his favorite booth, and refused to accept his money.
For a few hours each year, Cyrus could imagine that Daniel’s daughter had forgiven him, although he knew she had never been given the chance to decide.
The letter did not ask her to forgive him now.
It asked only that she understand the truth.
Roberta read the final lines aloud because the words were beginning to blur.
“Your father was brave, but he was also funny, impatient, and terribly bad at singing.”
“He worried about your mother, talked about buying a little house, and wanted to teach you how to swim.”
“He was not only the way he died.”
“He was the way he lived.”
Roberta covered her mouth.
For fifty-eight years, she had known Daniel Kane mainly through the fact of his absence.
Now, in a booth smelling of fresh coffee and warm toast, a dead man’s handwriting had restored the ordinary dreams that made his loss so large.
Devin waited until she lowered the page.
“There is one more thing,” he said.
Roberta looked at the strip of cloth in the transparent sleeve.
It was faded blue, with a tiny yellow star embroidered near one corner.
She knew it immediately.
Her mother had kept a yellow baby blanket in a cedar chest, but one corner had been cut away before Roberta was old enough to remember it.
Margaret always said the missing piece had been lost in the laundry.
“Where did he get this?” Roberta asked.
“Daniel carried it with him.”
Devin explained that Margaret had mailed Daniel a small square from Roberta’s blanket so he could keep something of his daughter close.
After Daniel’s death, the scrap had been recovered among his personal effects and passed to Cyrus with the rest of the items that had been gathered in the confusion.
Cyrus had kept it because he did not know where to send it.
He had intended to return it when he found the family.
Then he had carried it for so long that returning it became inseparable from confessing the truth.
Roberta took the sleeve in both hands.
The fabric was thin and worn, but the yellow star was still visible.