I asked whether she was certain of the date.

She said the event program and photographer’s invoice were still in her email.

I felt a dull pressure behind my eyes as I remembered Emily introducing Jason as a harmless old friend who needed a little encouragement.

Their connection to the land deal had apparently existed long before my engagement became a useful opportunity.

Sarah cautioned me against deciding that Emily had known everything from the beginning.

She said she was learning how many different stories Jason had told different people.

I thanked her for the warning because anger made simple explanations attractive.

The truth was usually less convenient.

That afternoon, I drove to the house Emily and I had shared and found two cardboard boxes waiting beside the front door.

She had texted to ask whether she could collect the rest of her belongings while I was at work.

I had agreed on the condition that Nathan’s wife, Laura, would be present and that Emily would not enter the workshop.

The boxes contained books, framed photographs, and a ceramic bowl we had bought on a weekend trip to Santa Fe.

I carried them inside because rain was beginning to fall.

One photograph showed Emily laughing at a picnic table while my father stood behind her with a paper plate in his hand.

He had liked her, and that knowledge still hurt in a way I could not explain to anyone.

My father had died believing I would be loved by the woman standing beside me.

I set the photograph facedown on the counter and went upstairs to change my shirt.

When I came back, Emily was standing in the kitchen with Laura near the doorway.

Emily looked exhausted, and her hair was pulled into a loose knot that made her seem younger than I remembered.

She said she had only come for the last box of winter clothes.

I told her Laura knew where everything was.

Emily glanced at the photograph on the counter and began crying.

She said my father had always treated her like family.

I answered that he had treated people well because he believed they would do the same when it mattered.

She pressed her lips together and asked whether we could talk privately.

I said we could speak with Laura present or arrange a conversation through Caroline.

Emily looked toward Laura, who quietly said she would wait in the living room within hearing distance.

I did not move from the kitchen doorway.

Emily said she had remembered something about the check.

She had seen Reddick hand Jason a thin blue folder during a dinner at a restaurant near Union Station.

Jason had told her it contained routine consulting invoices for a potential buyer.