His answer hurt because it was fair.

At the end of lunch, a woman approached our table carrying a worn leather folder.

She introduced herself as Grace Bell and said she had worked as an administrative coordinator for Jason’s consulting company.

I had never met her, but she knew my name.

Nathan immediately asked how she had found us.

Grace pointed toward Caroline’s office across the street.

She said she had been waiting for a meeting there and had recognized me from a photograph in a company file.

She did not ask to sit until I invited her.

Her hands shook slightly as she placed the folder on the table.

She said she had left Jason’s company six weeks earlier after refusing to alter a transaction log.

I asked whether she had reported the request.

She said she had sent a complaint to the company’s outside accountant and kept copies of her correspondence.

She wanted to speak to Caroline because she had heard that someone was challenging one of the company’s property agreements.

I told her she should take the folder directly to the attorney instead of discussing confidential records with me in a restaurant.

Grace looked surprised.

She said she had expected me to demand everything immediately.

I told her I was tired of people using secrets to control conversations.

She nodded and thanked me.

Before she left, she said something that stayed with me.

She said Jason did not usually create a problem unless he already knew who would be blamed for it.

Nathan watched her cross the street.

He asked whether I believed her.

I said I believed she had something she was frightened to carry alone.

That was all I knew.

Caroline called an hour later to confirm that Grace had made an appointment and had offered records for review.

She said the documents appeared relevant but would need to be authenticated.

I asked whether Grace had mentioned Emily.

Caroline paused before answering.

She said Emily’s name appeared in correspondence about the workshop transaction.

I asked whether the correspondence showed what Emily knew.

Caroline said it showed she had participated in scheduling meetings and transmitting documents.

It did not yet establish that she understood every part of Jason’s plan.

I wanted the distinction to disappear because certainty would have been easier than doubt.

Instead, I thanked Caroline for being precise.

That afternoon, Sarah asked to meet me at a public library near her sister’s home.

She said she had something important to explain about the call that had started everything.

I asked whether her attorney knew she was meeting me.

She said yes and that her sister would be nearby.

Nathan offered to drive, but I told him I could handle a conversation in a library.