I turned off the light knowing the next conversation could change the case again.
For the first time, I was not waiting for Emily to come home.
I was waiting for someone who had known my father to tell me what he remembered.
Caroline called the next afternoon while I was repairing a cabinet hinge in my father’s workshop.
She had spoken with Martin Vale for nearly two hours.
Her first words were not what I expected.
She said Martin had remembered my father clearly, but he had refused to sign a statement until he could examine a particular drawing.
I asked what drawing he wanted.
Caroline said he had described a hand-drafted survey of the eastern service lane, with a small red triangle near the creek crossing.
I put down my screwdriver.
The red triangle sounded familiar because my father used to mark unstable ground that way on his own working copies.
I told Caroline I might have the drawing in a cabinet at the workshop.
She asked me not to disturb the arrangement of the records until she could photograph the cabinet and document where anything was found.
That caution frustrated me for about ten seconds.
Then I remembered how many people had already used my father’s papers without permission.
I promised to wait.
Caroline said Martin had given her one detail that could not have come from the agreement Jason had circulated.
The eastern lane had never been intended as an ordinary access road.
It carried an easement for emergency vehicles and utility maintenance, and my father had insisted that any development preserve it.
Martin said the restriction had been discussed during an earlier sale that never closed.
The sale collapsed when the buyer demanded exclusive control of the creek crossing.
I asked whether Martin had a copy of that correspondence.
He did not know.
His daughter was sorting boxes after his move, and he had lost track of the records when his office closed.
Caroline had arranged to visit him again with a portable scanner.
She wanted me to understand that a retired man’s recollection could guide an investigation without proving a legal claim by itself.
I understood her distinction, although I desperately wanted one conversation to settle everything.
After the call, I stood in the workshop and studied the tall cabinet beside the old drafting table.
My father had built it from oak that was too knotty for his paying customers.
The bottom drawer still stuck in damp weather.
I had spent years walking past that cabinet without thinking about what it held.
Now every ordinary object seemed capable of becoming evidence.
I disliked the feeling because it turned my father’s familiar workspace into a place where I searched for threats.