I asked whether she had been promised money if the property changed hands.
She looked at Caroline instead of answering.
Caroline said Emily did not have to answer questions without obtaining her own legal advice.
Emily seized on the suggestion and said she wanted a lawyer.
I told her that was her right.
Then I asked one final question before she left.
Had she known that Sarah was frightened in her own house last night?
Emily stared at me.
She said Jason told her Sarah was visiting her sister.
I told her Sarah had been locked in a laundry room while a man demanded a flash drive.
Emily put a hand over her mouth.
For the first time since she walked through the door, her expression seemed genuinely unguarded.
She asked whether Sarah was alive.
I said she was safe.
Emily began to cry.
I wanted to believe those tears meant something.
I also knew tears could not explain a forged signature.
She whispered that Jason had told her everything would be finished by Friday.
Caroline asked what he meant by finished.
Emily shook her head and said she could not talk without a lawyer.
Then she left.
I watched the door close and realized I had not once asked her whether she still loved me.
The answer no longer seemed capable of changing what had happened.
At one thirty, Caroline received the copy of the deposit acknowledgment.
The account number on it belonged to a limited liability company connected to Front Range Residential Holdings.
The document was signed by a person claiming to act as my authorized representative.
That person’s printed name was Emily Harper.
Emily had not yet taken my last name.
She had used her own.
Caroline laid the document on the table without speaking.
I stared at Emily’s signature until the letters stopped looking familiar.
I remembered her laughing over wedding invitations because she had not decided whether to change her name.
I remembered promising that the choice was hers.
I had meant every word.
Now I was looking at her name beneath a statement that appeared to acknowledge money I had never received.
Nathan asked what we should do next.
Caroline said we would document the evidence, challenge the disputed filings, and cooperate with the appropriate investigators.
She also wanted an independent forensic review of the electronic documents.
I asked whether Emily could claim she had misunderstood what she signed.
Caroline said intent would depend on evidence we did not yet have.
I appreciated that she would not tell me what I wanted to hear.
The afternoon passed in a blur of calls and paperwork.
I notified my bank of the suspected identity misuse.
I placed appropriate alerts on my credit reports.