When he asked Lauren about the shirt, she repeated her account of the unknown driver.

He asked for a description of the vehicle.

She remembered a dark pickup with a white company decal on its door.

She could not remember the company name.

She remembered the driver’s hands because he had a small burn scar near his left thumb.

Reyes wrote that down as well.

At 3:18 a.m., Lauren’s regular phone rang.

The caller was Megan.

Lauren looked at me before answering.

“Where are you?” Megan asked, loud enough that I heard her across the table.

“I’m home.”

“Thank God.”

“What’s wrong?”

Megan hesitated.

“Tessa told me you left with a man.”

Lauren went completely still.

“What man?”

“She said he was waiting outside the restaurant.”

Lauren looked toward Officer Reyes.

“Megan, I left alone.”

“That’s what I thought.”

“Why would Tessa say that?”

Megan lowered her voice.

“Because she said he was your boyfriend.”

I watched Lauren’s expression change from fear to disbelief.

“That’s a lie,” she said.

“I know.”

“Where is Tessa now?”

“She isn’t answering me.”

Reyes asked Lauren to put the call on speaker and explain that an officer was present.

Megan agreed to provide her own account later that morning.

Before she hung up, she said something that made me sit straighter.

“Lauren, Tessa had your black dress in her car when she left.”

Lauren stared at the phone.

“How would she have my dress?”

“She told me you gave it to her.”

“I didn’t.”

The line went quiet.

Then Megan said, “I think you need to tell the police that.”

After the call, Reyes asked Lauren whether she wanted to amend anything in her statement.

She rubbed her eyes.

“I never saw Tessa after dinner,” she said.

“Could someone have taken your dress at the garage?”

“I left the torn dress near the stairwell.”

“Could Tessa have gone there?”

Lauren shook her head.

“She wasn’t supposed to know where I went.”

I heard the word supposed and understood that another piece of her story was missing.

“Did you tell Tessa about the photograph?” I asked.

Lauren didn’t answer immediately.

“I showed it to her at dinner.”

“What did she say?”

“She told me not to involve you until I knew whether it was real.”

I looked at Reyes.

He wrote something in his notebook.

“That doesn’t establish she did anything wrong,” he said, “but it gives us someone else to speak with.”

I appreciated that he didn’t turn suspicion into certainty.

I was already doing enough of that myself.

At four in the morning, the officers finished documenting the scene.

They arranged for the suspicious phone and key fob to be collected as potential evidence.