She touched the edge of the workbench and asked whether he had been kind to me.

I said yes.

She nodded, then looked away.

I knew the answer could not be simple for her.

The man who raised her son had also participated in keeping that son from her.

We did not force the conversation into forgiveness.

We simply let the truth stand between us without pretending it was easier than it was.

A month later Eli and his family came to Columbus.

We met at a public park because neither of us wanted our first meeting to feel like a ceremony.

He was taller than I expected, with dark hair beginning to gray at the temples.

We looked enough alike that a stranger might have guessed we were related, but we were not brothers by blood.

We were two men whose childhoods had crossed because adults treated names as paperwork instead of lives.

His daughters ran toward the playground while we sat on a bench and talked about the places we had lived.

He asked whether I still had the toy truck with the blue scratch.

I told him I did, and I had brought it.

Eli opened a small bag and took out the truck with the broken headlight.

We placed them side by side on the bench.

Neither of us spoke for a while.

Then he laughed softly and said he remembered arguing about which one was faster.

I laughed too, because I remembered the same argument, though I had never known who the other boy was.

The memory no longer felt like a trick my mind was playing.

It belonged to both of us.

We let the girls race the trucks along the bench, and for a few minutes the toys were only toys again.

Later that afternoon Eli asked whether I wanted to know what he remembered about Nora.

I said yes.

He told me she had been the person who drove him away from Linda Barrett’s house.

She had cried during the trip and told him he was going somewhere safe.

He remembered being angry because she would not take him back to Robert.

She had visited the Hales twice afterward, each time bringing a small gift and asking whether he was happy.

He had not known she was Lauren’s mother.

I listened without interrupting.

Nora had helped keep him alive and cared for, but she had also kept him separated from people who loved him.

Both things could be true.

When Eli left, he hugged me.

It was awkward at first, then easy.

He told me he hoped we would see each other again.