She had been eight when the second child disappeared.

We laid the photographs on the dining table.

In one picture, my father stood between two boys of similar height.

One wore a red sweater and smiled directly at the camera.

The other wore a yellow raincoat and looked toward the person taking the photograph.

Both faces resembled mine enough to make me uncomfortable.

Claire pointed to the red sweater.

“I think that was you,” she said.

Then she pointed to the raincoat.

“Or maybe it was him.” I did not blame her for the uncertainty.

Someone had made certain that she never had the chance to remember clearly.

A neighbor named Mrs.

Heller had taken some of the photographs.

She was eighty-three now and lived with her daughter in a retirement community outside Westerville.

Claire remembered her because she always brought homemade bread on Sundays.

We called and asked whether she would be willing to speak with Chen.

She agreed.

When the detective interviewed her, Mrs.

Heller said she remembered Robert caring for two little boys during one summer.

One had been recovering from a serious illness, and the other was frightened of being left alone.

She could not say which child had been which, but she remembered that Robert had begun calling both boys by the same nickname.

“Little E,” she said, smiling sadly.

Mrs.

Heller also remembered a woman visiting the house in a dark green station wagon.

The woman had argued with Robert on the porch, then left crying.

Mrs.

Heller had never known her name.

She had assumed it was a relative dealing with an unpleasant custody dispute.

When Chen showed her a selection of old photographs, she identified Nora Vale as the visitor, although she warned that her memory was not perfect.

That was enough to suggest a connection worth checking.

It was not enough to settle the question of what happened to either boy.

The next morning an envelope arrived at our lawyer’s office.

It contained a photocopy of a transportation invoice and a note signed with the initials E.H.

The invoice listed two children under the same destination code, but the dates did not match.

One line had been overwritten in blue ink.

The note said the original could be found in a former contractor warehouse scheduled for demolition.

I wanted to drive there immediately.

Our lawyer, Samuel Price, insisted that we give the information to Chen and stay away from the property.

He reminded me that finding evidence was different from preserving it, and that we had no right to enter a building merely because a stranger claimed something was inside.