Later that night, he found Laura sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of tea she had not touched.

“I heard Sophie get up,” she said.

“She’s asleep again.”

“She checked the basement door at Caroline’s house.”

Michael sat opposite her.

“I know.”

“She thought someone might be inside.”

“Caroline showed her that it’s only a storage closet.”

Laura wrapped her hands around the cup.

“How do we make her feel safe?”

“We keep showing her what safety looks like.”

They sat quietly until Michael’s phone vibrated.

The message was from Detective Ruiz.

Investigators had recovered a draft audio recording from a tablet used at the farmhouse.

The file had not been sent, but its contents could help establish the deception.

Ruiz asked whether Michael could come in the next morning.

He showed Laura the message.

She stared at it for a long time.

“Rebecca made recordings,” she said.

“I know.”

“Some were of me.”

“The detective mentioned that.”

Laura shook her head.

“No, Michael.”

Her voice became almost inaudible.

“She made recordings of herself pretending to be me.”

Michael remembered the phone calls from overseas.

The awkward pauses, the darkened screen, the explanations that the connection was poor.

“She practiced?” he asked.

Laura nodded.

“I could hear her upstairs repeating my words.”

Michael felt his stomach tighten.

“What words?”

Laura looked at him.

“The things I used to say when you called home.”

He stared at the table.

“Come back safe,” he whispered.

Laura’s eyes filled.

“Yes.”

Michael had heard that phrase from Rebecca more than once.

It had comforted him on nights when he was lonely and exhausted.

Now it felt like evidence of how carefully his family had been studied.

CHAPTER TWELVE: THE THIRD PERSON

The recovered audio file contained Rebecca rehearsing a telephone conversation.

Ruiz played a short portion after confirming that Michael wanted to hear it.

Rebecca’s voice sounded almost exactly like Laura’s.

She repeated Michael’s name, laughed at a joke that nobody had told, and practiced saying that Sophie was already asleep.

Then another voice entered the recording.

A man’s voice told her she was speaking too quickly.

Michael recognized Gavin.

He expected the file to end there.

Instead, a second man spoke from farther away.

“He’ll ask about the account before he asks about the house.”

Michael looked at Ruiz.

“Who’s that?”

“We believe it may be Harold Mercer.”

The recording continued.

The distant voice told Rebecca to mention the family trust only if Michael brought it up first.

Then it suggested that she complain about Sophie’s behavior to explain why the child might not appear on camera.

Michael asked Ruiz to stop the playback.

He needed a moment.

The people behind the deception had not simply improvised excuses.