Laura touched the screen.
“She’s so thin.”
“The doctors are checking her health,” Michael said.
“Dana is helping us arrange follow-up care.”
Laura nodded.
“Did she tell you about the kitchen table?”
“Yes.”
“I heard Rebecca shouting at her.”
Laura’s voice broke.
“I could hear Sophie crying through the floor.”
Michael moved closer.
“You couldn’t get out.”
“I tried every day.”
“I know.”
“No, Michael, I need you to understand.”
She looked directly at him.
“There were days when I could hear her calling for me, and I couldn’t even tell her I was alive.”
Michael held her hand until she stopped shaking.
He did not tell her to forget.
He did not promise that everything would return to normal.
He promised only that Sophie would not be left alone with Rebecca again.
That evening Ruiz called with another discovery.
The basement notebook contained a name Michael did not recognize.
Harold Mercer.
According to Laura’s entries, Mercer had visited the house several times and discussed a notarized statement with Gavin.
“Who is he?” Michael asked.
“A local property consultant,” Ruiz replied.
“We’re looking into his involvement.”
“Did he know Laura was downstairs?”
“That’s one of the questions we need answered.”
Michael looked toward the bedroom where Sophie was sleeping at his sister’s house.
He had brought her there because the Bennett home was still being processed and because familiar family members could help her feel safe.
“If other people came to that house,” he said, “someone may have seen my daughter.”
“We are checking that.”
“Then somebody had a chance to help her.”
Ruiz was silent for a moment.
“Possibly.”
CHAPTER EIGHT: WHAT THE NEIGHBOR HEARD
Michael’s sister, Caroline Bennett, lived twenty minutes away in a quiet subdivision.
She had driven to the hospital as soon as he called and had not left Sophie’s side until the child fell asleep.
Caroline was forty-two, a school librarian, and the person Sophie had once called whenever she wanted to hear a bedtime story about animals.
Rebecca had told Caroline that Laura needed space from extended family while Michael was overseas.
She had also claimed that Sophie was attending a special summer program.
Caroline had sent birthday cards and small gifts, but most had been returned with brief messages saying the family was traveling.
“I should have driven over,” Caroline told Michael.
“I should have insisted.”
Michael recognized the guilt because he felt it too.
“She worked to keep us apart,” he said.
“That matters.”
Caroline wiped her eyes.
“I keep thinking about that little girl under the table.”
“So do I.”
The next afternoon, a neighbor named Mrs. Evelyn Price called Caroline.
She lived across the road from the Bennett property and had heard about the investigation.