Claire answered that she had kept an important secret from our family because she was frightened.
She said that was a mistake and that she was working to put it right.
Emma thought about the answer.
Then she asked whether she could still go to her friend’s birthday party on Saturday.
The question nearly made me cry.
I told her we would check with the adults helping us stay safe.
That afternoon, Ben accompanied me to our house to collect Emma’s winter coat and school project.
Nora had said a brief visit was acceptable if we took ordinary precautions.
The maple tree had dropped leaves across the driveway.
A delivery notice hung crookedly from the front door.
I unlocked the house and stood in the hallway without moving.
The place smelled like our laundry detergent and the lemon cleaner Claire used on the counters.
Nothing looked different.
That made it worse.
Ben waited while I went upstairs.
Emma’s science project stood beside her bed, a cardboard model of the solar system with one planet hanging by a thread.
I placed it carefully in a box.
On Claire’s dresser, I noticed the blouse she had been wearing before the night she came home in the blue work shirt.
It had been washed and folded.
I remembered how certain I had been that the shirt meant another man.
I had treated my fear as evidence before I knew what was happening.
Downstairs, Ben called my name.
He had found an envelope wedged beneath the front door.
There was no stamp and no return address.
Inside was a single printed sentence.
Your wife is not the only one who knows what happened to the girl.
Ben photographed the paper where it lay and called Nora.
He told me not to handle it again.
I stepped away from the counter.
My first impulse was to run outside and search the street.
Then I pictured Emma asking whether she could attend a birthday party.
I stayed where I was.
An investigator collected the envelope less than an hour later.
Nora said it could be a threat, an attempt to frighten us, or a message from someone seeking contact.
She would not pretend to know which.
When we returned to Ben’s apartment, Emma was cutting stars from yellow construction paper.
I sat beside her and helped with the scissors.
For twenty minutes, the most important thing in my life was making sure Saturn had a ring.
CHAPTER TWELVE: THE MAN WHO LENT THE SHIRT