Elise said Paula had told the hospital board that Sophie was released according to protocol.
But the original nurse’s notes contradicted that statement.
Elise had copied those notes before they disappeared.
She had left the copies in the storage unit.
Claire told her investigators had found the unit.
Elise sounded relieved.
Then she said she had one more thing to tell us.
A woman had come to the farmhouse that morning claiming to be from the hospital.
She carried flowers and asked to speak with Elise alone.
The farmer’s wife refused to let her inside.
The visitor left a card with no name, only a telephone number.
Elise read the number aloud.
Claire wrote it on the back of a grocery receipt.
I recognized the last four digits.
They belonged to Martin Vale’s personal phone.
Elise said she had already given the card to the state investigator.
She asked Claire not to call it.
Claire promised she would not.
After the call ended, we sat in silence beside the school parking lot.
I could hear children shouting on the playground beyond the fence.
Claire looked at the receipt in her hand.
She said Martin had been her friend for nearly a decade.
He had attended Emma’s birthday parties and brought soup when I had pneumonia.
I told her those memories did not prove he was innocent.
She said she knew.
Then she asked whether I thought we would ever feel safe in our own house again.
I looked at the morning traffic moving past the school.
I wanted to promise her that everything would be normal by the end of the week.
Instead, I told her we would find out what happened, protect Emma, and make decisions together.
Claire folded the receipt and put it in her purse.
She reached across the console and took my hand.
We were still sitting there when Nora called with an update from the rural property.
Investigators had found a child’s bedroom prepared for someone who had recently stayed there.
They had found Sophie’s name written inside a library book.
But the room was empty.
And on the kitchen table was a photograph of Sophie standing beside a woman neither Nora nor Claire recognized.
The photograph had been taken that morning.
CHAPTER NINE: THE PHOTOGRAPH TAKEN THAT MORNING
Nora did not send the photograph to our phones.
She asked us to return to the state office, where an investigator could show it to us without creating another uncontrolled copy.