The dates matched the birthday I had celebrated with my mother every spring.

The certificates listed the same parents.

“Why did nobody tell me?” I asked.

Claire glanced at Margaret.

“Because something happened when they were young,” she said.

“Something that tore the family apart.”

Margaret shook her head gently.

“We should be careful about how much we claim to know.”

“There are letters, and there are records, but not every family accusation was ever proven.”

I felt an ugly flash of impatience.

“I didn’t drive an hour to hear everyone speak in riddles.”

Margaret accepted the rebuke without looking offended.

“Your mother asked Evelyn to stay away from you when you were a child,” she said.

“She believed distance was the only way to keep an old family dispute from reaching you.”

“What dispute?”

Claire finally sat down.

“Our grandfather controlled a trust that was supposed to pay for treatment and support for family members who needed it.”

“After he died, the money became the center of a bitter argument.”

“Your father accused my mother of trying to take control of it.”

“My mother accused your father of concealing documents.”

I remembered my father sitting at the dining room table with unopened envelopes spread in front of him.

I remembered the way he had slammed a drawer shut whenever I entered the room.

At the time, I thought he was worried about household bills.

“What does any of that have to do with Daniel?”

Margaret turned over the next page.

It was a letter in my mother’s handwriting, dated shortly before her death.

I recognized the rounded capital R and the way she crossed her sevens.

The letter was addressed to Daniel Carter.

I stared at the name until the letters blurred.

Daniel and I had not met until years after my mother died.

“That’s impossible,” I said.

Margaret looked at me with visible sympathy.

“Daniel’s father was your mother’s attorney during the final months of her life.”

“Daniel helped organize the old files after his father became ill.”

“He found this letter when he was twenty-three.”

I calculated the years automatically.

That was the year before Daniel and I met at a charity fundraiser in Columbus.

I had always described that meeting as a coincidence.

Now I wasn’t sure what to call it.

“Did he know who I was when he introduced himself?”

Margaret hesitated.

“That is a question you need to ask him.”

The answer made me angrier than a confession would have.