The first was affectionate and ordinary.

The second described an argument about money that had frightened her.

The third contained a sentence that made my hands go cold.

“If Victor approaches Rachel when she is older, tell her what happened before she believes anything he says about Evelyn.”

My mother had written the sentence two months before her death.

I read it again, hoping the words would rearrange themselves into something less terrible.

They did not.

Below the letter lay a small photograph of my mother and Evelyn standing outside a brick building with a brass plaque.

The plaque carried the name of a family charitable trust.

On the back, my mother had written a date and four words.

“Ask about the second account.”

I called Helen and read the words aloud.

For the first time since meeting her, she stopped speaking for several seconds.

Then she asked me to bring the entire envelope to her office the next morning.

I wanted to ask why, but the answer arrived before I could speak.

Somebody had rung my doorbell.

Through the upstairs window, I saw Tyler standing beneath Daniel’s porch light.

He was alone, and his expression no longer resembled the confident smile that had once impressed me.

I turned off the attic flashlight and remained still.

Tyler rang the bell again.

Then my phone vibrated with a message from him.

“Victor knows you found something, and you need to call me before he gets angry.”

I looked at the open envelope in my hands.

Nobody outside Helen’s office knew I was searching the attic.

I wondered whether Tyler was guessing or whether somebody had been watching the house.

Either possibility frightened me enough to call the police nonemergency number and report the unwanted visit.

I did not open the door.

Tyler eventually drove away, leaving me alone with a question that had been waiting in a cardboard box for nearly two decades.

What had my mother discovered about the second account?

CHAPTER NINE: THE WOMAN WHO REFUSED TO DISAPPEAR

Evelyn agreed to meet me the following afternoon at the medical center.

Margaret led me into a quiet room overlooking a courtyard where wet leaves clung to the benches.

Evelyn sat beside the window with a knitted blanket across her knees.

She looked older than the woman in Daniel’s photograph, but I recognized my mother’s smile immediately.

I had spent my childhood wishing I could hear that smile in somebody else’s voice.

Now I was frightened by how much I wanted to embrace a woman I barely knew.