Ruth identified the original drainage plan and a later revision that shifted a runoff channel closer to the unstable slope.
She explained that the revision required additional calculations and reinforcement that she had not seen documented.
Dr. Ortiz examined the drawings and asked whether any construction photographs showed the installed drainage system.
Emily produced several images from Michael’s hidden box.
The photographs showed a concrete channel and exposed earth beside the retaining wall, but their angles were not sufficient to establish every dimension.
Ruth pointed to a distinctive pipe junction and said the photographs appeared to show the revised configuration.
Dr. Ortiz cautioned that he would need survey information, weather records, and construction logs before offering an opinion on causation.
Emily appreciated his refusal to rush.
Her father’s warnings deserved the same care he had tried to bring to the project.
During a break, Ruth asked Emily whether Michael had ever told her about the afternoon he stopped a delivery truck from entering the lower access road.
Emily said she had never heard that story.
Ruth explained that Michael noticed the road had begun to crack after heavy rain and insisted the driver use the upper entrance.
The driver complained about the delay, but the next morning a section of the lower road had collapsed.
Ruth said Michael had been difficult to intimidate because he cared more about getting people home safely than keeping a schedule.
Emily smiled through sudden tears.
That sounded like the father she remembered, the man who would turn the car around to help a stranger change a tire even when dinner was getting cold.
She wished Susan had lived long enough to hear somebody outside the family describe him that way.
At the end of the session, Dr. Ortiz requested additional records and declined to draw a final conclusion.
Caroline said the review would continue and that any findings would be documented in writing.
Emily left with a sense of progress that did not depend on a dramatic confession.
The truth was beginning to take the form of a record other people could examine.
Two days later, a court authorized a limited inspection of records held by Northfield Services after the company failed to respond adequately to a lawful production request.
The order did not authorize an unrestricted search of the storage facility.
It identified specific categories of documents connected to Ashford Ridge, the relevant dates, and the account associated with Unit Twelve.