Nathan accepted her answer without attempting to improve it.

At noon, Caroline received a response from the county clerk concerning the old Ashford Ridge permit files.

The clerk had found a reference to a supplemental engineering review dated four days before the collapse.

The review itself was missing from the scanned archive, but its tracking number appeared in an index.

That detail mattered because the index had been generated automatically by the county’s records system.

Somebody had submitted a document, even if the document could no longer be found in its usual place.

Caroline filed a preservation request covering the index, its backups, and any archived correspondence associated with the tracking number.

She also contacted an independent structural engineer who had no connection to the original project.

Emily listened as Caroline explained each step, and the slow pace of legitimate investigation frustrated her more than she expected.

She wanted a door to open and every answer to be waiting behind it.

Instead, the truth seemed to live in boxes, invoices, damaged recordings, and memories that had faded around the edges.

Nathan offered to drive her home, but Emily asked to visit the cemetery first.

The snow had stopped, leaving the road shoulders piled high beneath a sky the color of unpolished silver.

Michael Parker’s grave stood beneath a maple tree near the older section of the grounds.

Emily brushed snow from the small stone with her glove and placed the compass against its base.

She told her father that she had heard his voice that morning.

She told him she was angry that the world had made him defend the truth while other people protected their money.

She admitted that she was frightened by how much she still did not know.

Then she said she would bring the compass home because she finally understood why he had taught her to use it.

He had wanted her to find her way without surrendering her judgment to somebody who spoke more loudly.

Nathan waited beside the path until she was ready to leave.

He did not ask whether she felt better, because both of them knew grief was not a problem that could be solved in one afternoon.

On the drive back, Emily noticed a message from June, the waitress who had worked beside her at the diner for three years.

June said Richard Collins was telling customers that Emily had staged the Christmas Eve incident to attract attention from a wealthy family.