The sender was controlling when information reached us, which photographs we saw, and how frightened we became.
“Someone is using the truth as bait,” Laura said.
“And using Rachel’s reputation to make sure you keep following.”
“Do you think Michael is involved?”
“I don’t know.”
“What do you think they want?”
“The missing binder is still the most obvious target.”
I looked at the conference room door.
“Then whoever has it may already have what they need.”
“Unless the binder was incomplete.”
Her words stayed with me all afternoon.
I went home and searched my father’s remaining notebooks again.
Most pages contained dates and warehouse inventory numbers.
One notebook had a section devoted to household repairs.
I almost put it aside until I noticed an entry from the week before his death.
It listed a replacement lock for the garage, a new smoke detector, and a small steel document box.
Beside the document box, my father had written two words.
Not basement.
I stared at the note.
He had known somebody might search the basement.
He had also known that a box hidden in an obvious place would not stay hidden.
I walked through the house looking for anything that had belonged to him before Rachel and I moved in.
There was an old workbench, a set of hand tools, and a wooden cabinet he had built for my mother.
The cabinet stood in our upstairs hallway.
It held spare blankets and a few books.
I opened its doors and removed the shelves.
Nothing appeared unusual.
Then I noticed a narrow strip of wood beneath the bottom shelf.
It had been fastened with two screws that did not match the others.
I fetched a screwdriver and loosened them.
Behind the strip was a shallow compartment.
Inside lay a small brass key wrapped in wax paper.
The key looked like the one in the first reunion photograph.
A number was stamped on its head.
417.
I stood in the hallway holding the key while my heart hammered.
The anonymous sender had photographed a key that matched one hidden in my father’s cabinet.
That meant the sender knew about the compartment, or had access to a second key.
I called Laura before moving anything else.
She asked me to photograph the compartment, the wrapping, and the key in place.
Then she advised me to put everything back until we could document it properly.
I followed her instructions.
Rachel appeared at the end of the hallway.
“What did you find?” she asked.
I showed her the photographs on my phone.
Her face tightened.
“That is the same key.”
“It looks identical.”
“The number is the same.”
“Yes.”
She leaned against the wall.
“Daniel, I think the man who organized the reunion has been in this house.”
“Why?”
“Because he knew where your father kept things.”