I agreed.

Then Margaret called my cell phone that evening.

Her voice was pleasant and careful.

She asked whether Connor was home.

I told her we were separated.

There was a long silence.

Margaret said she was sorry to hear it.

Then she asked whether I could give her his new address.

I refused.

She sounded surprised.

I explained that Connor would decide what contact he wanted.

Margaret said that families should not keep secrets from one another.

The remark was so unexpected that I almost laughed.

I thought of the letters Connor had written to Hannah and never mailed.

I asked Margaret why she had told Connor that Hannah did not want to hear from him.

Her tone changed immediately.

She said I had been listening to gossip.

I answered that Hannah had found the letters after their aunt died.

Margaret insisted she had been protecting her children from disappointment.

I asked whose disappointment she meant.

She did not answer.

Instead, she said Connor had always been stubborn.

I heard myself preparing to defend him with the same certainty I once used to criticize him.

I told her that she should speak to him directly if he chose to answer.

Then I ended the call.

For several minutes, I stood beside the window and watched rain collect along the sill.

I had spent months demanding that Connor account for every movement after he stopped accounting for mine.

Margaret’s call showed me how easily concern could become a claim of ownership.

I sent Connor a short message through the communication channel we had agreed to use.

I told him his mother had contacted me and asked for his address.

I said I had not shared it.

He replied later that night.

He thanked me for respecting his privacy.

Then he added that Margaret had been calling Hannah as well.

I asked whether he wanted me to do anything.

He said no.

I put down my phone.

For once, I did not mistake his refusal for a challenge.

[End of Chapter Eleven]

CHAPTER TWELVE — BLAKE’S SECOND VERSION

Blake appeared outside my office on a Wednesday afternoon.

I had not seen him since ending the affair.

He stood beside a silver sedan, wearing the expensive coat he used to leave across restaurant chairs.

He smiled as though we had merely missed a few dates.

I stopped several feet away.

I asked why he was there.

He said my silence had been dramatic and unnecessary.

I told him the relationship was over.

Blake glanced toward the building entrance.