He described Samuel carrying trays during a snowstorm when half the staff could not reach the restaurant.
He remembered the way Samuel greeted the dishwashers by name.
Then he told Marissa something that made her eyes fill.
“Your father once told me he hoped his daughter would grow up kinder than the world expected her to be.”
Marissa covered her mouth.
“I don’t remember him saying that.”
“He said it when you were little.”
Walter leaned forward.
“He was proud of you long before you were old enough to understand what pride meant.”
Marissa took a tissue from the box on the table.
“I wish I’d known him as an adult.”
Walter nodded.
“I wish he’d had the chance.”
Priya asked Walter whether he remembered anything about the old ownership dispute.
He thought for a moment.
“There was a man who used to meet Samuel after closing,” he said.
“His name was Martin something.”
“Martin Hale?” Priya asked.
Walter snapped his fingers.
“That’s him.”
Priya glanced at Marissa.
Martin Hale had been the accountant responsible for the original profit-sharing reports.
He had disappeared from the business records shortly after Samuel’s dispute began.
“Do you know where he went?” Priya asked.
Walter shook his head.
“But he had a daughter who worked at a bookstore near Lincoln Square.”
He named the shop.
Priya wrote it down.
It was the first useful lead they had received from someone who had no financial interest in the case.
That evening, Marissa and Priya visited the bookstore.
A bell chimed when they entered.
The shop smelled of old paper and coffee, and a sleepy orange cat occupied the front window.
A woman in her forties looked up from a stack of invoices.
Priya introduced herself and asked whether she was related to Martin Hale.
The woman’s expression changed immediately.
“My father died last year,” she said.
Marissa felt disappointment settle over her.
The woman noticed.
“Why are you looking for him?”
Marissa explained that her father had worked at Harper’s Table.
The woman’s hand stopped moving across the invoice.
“Samuel Bennett?”
“Yes.”
“My father talked about him.”
Marissa stepped closer.
“What did he say?”
The woman introduced herself as Claire Hale and invited them into a small office behind the shelves.
She said Martin had spent the final years of his life trying to correct a mistake from his accounting career.
He had never explained the whole story, but he had kept a locked filing cabinet in his basement.