A faded photograph of Samuel hung above a small table.
He wore a work jacket and held a fishing rod that was almost as tall as Grace had been.
She touched the frame.
She had spent twenty years speaking to that photograph as though it marked a fixed ending.
Now the ending had moved beyond her reach.
Ruth came to stand beside her.
She said they did not need to decide what to believe before the evidence was ready.
Grace leaned her head against her mother’s shoulder.
She said she wanted the truth even if it changed every story they had told themselves.
Ruth said she wanted it too.
Outside, rain began tapping against the windows.
Grace remembered the night she found Arthur beside the road and the simple choice that brought him into her life.
She had thought she was helping a stranger get home.
Instead, she had opened a road toward a past her family had been forbidden to examine.
She did not know where that road would end.
She knew only that she would not turn away while there was still a chance to find her father.
The following morning, Grace woke to the sound of her mother moving furniture in the kitchen.
Ruth had pulled the old cedar chest away from the wall and was kneeling beside it with a stack of envelopes in her lap.
The chest had belonged to Samuel, and nobody had opened its lower compartment since the year after the flood.
Grace asked what her mother was looking for.
Ruth said she remembered a letter that had arrived after the funeral and that she had never understood why it had been sent.
The envelope had carried no return address, and the message inside had consisted of a single sentence written in careful block letters.
Grace unfolded the paper while Ruth watched her face.
The message instructed Ruth to ask the county clerk about the name assigned to the unidentified patient from the north road.
Ruth said she had taken the letter to the sheriff’s office, where a deputy dismissed it as a cruel prank.
She had kept it because Samuel had always told her that a document should be preserved until somebody could explain it.
Grace examined the paper without pretending that the handwriting identified its author.
She photographed the envelope and called Helen before either woman could build a theory around it.
Helen asked them not to handle it further and arranged for a member of Mara’s team to collect it that afternoon.